Question 1

What do you judge?

Accepted Answer

Any AI product being sold or marketed to a business or a consumer — B2B AI software (sales tools, dev tools, support tools, analytics, HR tech, marketing platforms) and B2C AI apps (productivity, wellness, finance, photo/video, and so on). If a company is charging money for something with 'AI' in the pitch, it's fair game.

Question 2

How do you judge?

Accepted Answer

A curated panel of critics actually uses the product, then writes a review and casts a verdict: Slop or Not. The Slop Score on each product page is just the percentage of critics who said Slop. Low score is good news, high score means most critics think it's slop — a score of 15% means 85% of critics said it wasn't slop.

Question 3

Why do you judge?

Accepted Answer

Every AI product launch comes with the same confident marketing copy, so it's genuinely hard to tell from a landing page whether something is a real product or a thin wrapper riding the hype cycle. We exist to cut through that with real usage and real opinions, so buyers can tell the difference before they sign a contract or a subscription.

Question 4

What does the Slop Score actually mean?

Accepted Answer

It's the percentage of critics who voted Slop. 0–49% lands a Not verdict, 50–100% lands a Slop verdict. It's intentionally the inverse of a normal review score — a low number is what you want to see.

Question 5

Who are the critics?

Accepted Answer

A curated panel, not an open public vote — the same model Rotten Tomatoes uses for its Tomatometer. Each critic reviews a product firsthand and writes up what actually happened, good or bad.

Question 6

Can I submit a company to be reviewed?

Accepted Answer

Yes — anyone can submit a company, no account required. Submissions go to our critics, who review the product and add it to the leaderboard.